Starter Phone Guide

Kid-safe phones compared

Written by the Starter Phone Guide Research Desk. Facts checked November 20, 2026.

How we earn: some links to device makers may pay us a commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we say, and we list free options where they do the job. We have not tested these devices ourselves; comparisons come from makers' own pages and published reviews. More on how we earn.

These phones share a goal but not a method. Some leave features out, some curate apps, and some monitor. The table puts each maker's published details next to each other.

Gabb Phone 4Bark Phone (Samsung A16)Pinwheel phones (Plus 6, Slim 6, Genesis 4)Troomi phone (Samsung Galaxy A17 5G)MMGuardian app and MMGuardian Phone
TypeKid-safe phoneKid-safe phoneKid-safe phoneKid-safe phonePhone and monitoring app
Device price$229.99$260$299Not shown$299
Activation fee$30None listedNone listedNone listedNone listed
Cheapest no-contract plan$34.99/mo$29/mo$17.99/mofrom $24.95/mo$4.99/mo
Two-year total$1,100$956$731$599$419
Web browserNoStarter: none. Advanced: parent chooses which browsers are allowedNo web browser by defaultOptional Troomi Smart Browser limited to approved sites (Discover)–
App storeNoStarter: none. Advanced: open Google Play, approve each app, or block the store1,000+ pre-vetted apps; Google Play can be enabled except social media and adult appsCurated Troomi App Store only–
Social mediaNoStarter: none. Advanced: allowed under parent rulesNoNot offered on any plan–
Calls and messagesUnlimited talk and text, group texting; picture messaging listed as a Standard plan featureTalk and text; Bark scans texts, social media, photos, videos and apps and sends alertsOnly approved numbers can call or text; image texting per contact; remote text monitoringApproved contacts; AI monitors texts and images and blurs explicit contentMessage access, web monitoring, app blocking, location
LocationYes, location updates about every 15 minutesYesYes, with arrive/leave alertsYes–
Camera13 MP rear, 5 MP frontSamsung A16 cameraVaries by model––
School-hour featuresNot named on the plans pageAdvanced plan includes screen-time schedules (e.g., school hours, bedtime) and app limitsSchedules can make the phone act like a basic phone during set times such as schoolNot named on the page–
NetworkNot stated on the pageNot named (Bark says 'nationwide network')Pinwheel Wireless or your own carrierAT&T networkYour choice of carrier
Maker's age guidancePlans labeled ages 12–14 (Standard) and 14+ (Advanced)Not statedNot stated––

From each maker's page on November 20, 2026. Two-year total is our arithmetic: device price we saw, plus activation, plus 24 months of the cheapest no-contract plan, before taxes.

Three approaches

  • Leave it out: Gabb Phone 4, with no browser or app store.[1]
  • Curate: Pinwheel and Troomi, with vetted apps and no social media.[4][7]
  • Monitor: Bark, which scans content and can open up over time, and MMGuardian, which offers a monitoring app and a tamper-resistant phone.[3][8]

Gabb Phone 4 Bark Phone Pinwheel phones Troomi phone MMGuardian app and MMGuardian Phone

Sources

  1. Gabb: plans
  2. Gabb: home page
  3. Bark: bark phone
  4. Pinwheel: home page
  5. Pinwheel: pricing
  6. Pinwheel: plus 6
  7. Troomi: home page
  8. MMGuardian: home page

Checked November 20, 2026. If something here is out of date, tell us.